7649 Tuttle Road Cicero NY 13030 MLS #S1610189

Whether you’re seeking a weekend escape, year-round lakefront living, or a prime short-term rental investment, this exceptional property delivers. This move-in-ready cottage blends comfort and functionality, beautifully situated on 50 feet of private waterfront.
While the cottage currently features one bedroom, the original blueprints from a 1995 renovation show a design intended for two. Additionally, the guest suite above the garage could easily be reconfigured to include two bedrooms—allowing the property to comfortably host larger groups while maintaining privacy for guests. As a short-term rental, this space offers excellent income potential.
The cottage’s main level features an open-concept layout with wide wood plank flooring and a full wall of windows, offering stunning lake views from nearly every angle. The living area flows directly onto a lakeside patio, while the kitchen includes island seating and a designated dining space. A convenient half bath and laundry nook complete the main floor.
Upstairs, you’ll find a generously sized bedroom—easily convertible into two separate rooms—along with a full bath.
What truly sets this property apart is the newly constructed, two-story barn-style garage—thoughtfully designed for both utility and enjoyment. The upper level offers nearly 1,000 square feet of finished living space with a full bathroom, perfect for hosting guests, extended family, or generating rental income.
The lower level boasts over 1,500 square feet of heated space with a full kitchen. It has 6-inch poured concrete floors, radiant heat, 12-foot overhead doors, a car lift, hot/cold exterior water hookup, and electrical outlets every eight feet—making it ideal for a workshop, recreational storage, or hobbyist space.
Located on a quiet, private road and serviced by public water and sewer, this home is as practical as it is picturesque. With endless recreational opportunities right outside your door, this is lakeside living at its finest.